Monday, October 29, 2012

Negation

A fundamental part of what I understand is happening in Molloy revolves around the idea of negation or undoing. So often, what Molloy himself says is negated by immediate literal contradiction or by undermining the possibility of his feelings, as in “I felt more or less the same as usual...so terror-stricken that I was virtually bereft of feeling” (p 72). In some cases, this negation seems to be beyond Molloy’s control -- his body steadily becomes unable or even absent. Molloy’s foot (whichever) becomes defined by its lack of toes, his legs by their inability to convey him. In other ways, negation appears to be a definable goal of Molloy, e.g. “I was bent double over a heap of muck, in the hope of finding something to disgust me for ever with eating” (p. 77). I suppose I would ask, what is the purpose of Molloy’s project of writing, why does it seem so crucial to negate statements, experience, and his body?

Language in Molloy

I wasn't in class on Thursday, and so I hope I'm not bringing up a topic that has already been discussed.  I'd like to focus my blog post on language and Beckett's invention of words in the text (which we have seen in previous texts). How might his experimentation with words benefit or inhibit the text and our reading of it? How might it compare with the use of language in Lessing's The Golden Notebook or Green's Loving?

I have some examples: "pitilessmost" and "corncrakes"(21); "index-knuckle" (23); "connexion" (28); "raglimp" (34); "sucking-stone" (59); "coenaesthetically" (72); and "floccillate" (89).

While I think words such as these are fun to come across, we can only somewhat decipher their meaning (some better than others--though many derive from actual words or mirror them closely). It's interesting to examine these in contrast to the simpler language. Take page 56. If you look at this page as a whole, the word "I" prominently jumps out to the eye. They're a series of first person, simple sentences. Compare: "The next day I demanded my clothes" (56) to "But sucking-stones abound on our beaches, when you know where to look for them, and I deemed it wiser to say nothing about it..." etc. (59).

Where do these words get us? They're becoming less fun, and more like little frustrations for me as I'm writing this blog post. Where does this experimentation with language get us, besides confusion?

Saturday, October 27, 2012

Life & Death

"But it is only since I have ceased to live that I think of these things and the other things. It is in the tranquility of decomposition that I remember the long confused emotion which was my life, and that I judge it, as it is said that God will judge me too, and with no less impertinence. To decompose is to live too, I know, I know, don't torment me, but one sometimes forgets." (p 32-3)
Is Molloy an account of life after death? Is Molloy even alive, or does he mean "ceased to live" less literally? Perhaps he has changed or evolved or regressed into a new person with a new way of life. The idea that decomposition is life too means that life goes on once we have perished. Do life and death have to contradict each other? I am not sure, clearly, if Molloy is alive or dead. But I am leaning toward the thought that he is telling this story of his life post-death. Maybe.

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Molloy

Reading the beginning of Molloy, I was thinking of a topic we discussed a few times in class, about how we visualize the story we are reading. Several people said they see it almost like a movie playing in front of them. I usually read this way, too. For Molloy, it feels different. I see it almost as a movie, but I feel more inside Molloy's head. It is a very internal type of narration where Molloy is witnessing events but instead of taking them for their external value, tries to come up with internal reasonings. I think I'm just wondering if anyone else thinks it feels different. The repetition of words and phrases increase this internal feel where I see the story unfold through Molloy's eyes yet still see him externally at the same time. My mind is also making weird connections at the moment due to stress and lack of sleep, so my point is: does anyone else view it this way?

Molloy; Or, the Poop Stories


There’s so much going on in Molloy, it’s hard to pick a single thing to write about. Some things I really wanted to touch on is the lack of a determined setting – England? Ireland? Somewhere with hills. And so far, the majority of what we’ve read has taken place while Molloy is riding his bicycle (not a bike. Bicycle), which I think is blog post-worthy. But, finally I decided on something much more important: poop.

Well, not poop in general. Molloy has many, many allusions to the body (particularly his), but they are all grungy and generally always unhygienic. Especially when he decides to spend a few lines talking about carrying around newspaper to wipe with – but not after every poop, only sometimes, if he feels like it. Molloy also uses phrases like “pain in the balls” (52), refers to the back of the moon as “her arse” (52), and talks about festering wounds if he were to remove his own testicles with shears. Beckett is definitely using a lot of grotesque, anatomical(ish) imagery – but why? One theory I want to propose occurs on page 52, after a particular nasty stream of narration, in which Molloy mentions in passing, “What I liked in anthropology was its inexhaustible faculty of negation, its relentless definition of man, as if he were no better than God” (52). This implies an equality between man and deity (and, if man is defined, mankind has a single definition – everyone is the same). This, paired with the clear lack of distinction between the “characters” A and C, supports the theme that everyone is the same, which leads me to believe that perhaps Beckett is trying to convey that everyone has bodily functions, therefore we should have no problem discussing them (Molloy certainly has no hesitation with it).

I think Molloy’s “birth” on page 20 is also worth commenting on, but this is already a long post. But it might be a good place for comments to stem from. 

Saul as Karma?

Let me begin by apologizing for this post being so late.

this is something I've been thinking about ever since Saul first came into The Golden Notebook. I remember feeling that, at the point right before Saul came into the picture, the book had reached a point were it could have ended. It could have stopped when all the other journals had come to an end, or when Anna goes to talk to Tommy and Marion, or when Molly and Richard come to talk with Anna afterwards. To me it felt like this moment would have provided a satisfactory ending in that, all the problems that were established in the very beginning of the novel, during a very similar conversation between Anna, Molly, and Richard (What to do with Tommy, how Richard had been treating Marion, etc.) had all been resolved. Marion has finally left Richard, Anna is finally able to influence Tommy, and when the three part, it is actually on a somewhat friendly note, unlike the first time when Richard leaves in anger and Molly and Anna part on seemingly shaky ground. 

And then along comes Saul, and a small part of me couldn't help but wonder if maybe Saul's appearance, and how he throws Anna's life into disarray once again, wasn't some sort of karma. Maybe I'm being cruel to Anna, and I'm not saying that what Saul did was excusable, but when Anna was looking through Saul's diary and she began to grow jealous of how he was sleeping with other women, all i could think was "the mistress has finally become the victim". After all of the affairs that Anna had knowingly been a part of, after all the times she slept with men she knew were married, she was finally the one who was being cheated on. I say that she was "the wife" in this case and that the other women Saul slept with were "the mistress's" because Anna was the one that Saul actually lived with. just like the men Anna had affairs with would go back to their wives, Saul would go back to her. Just as all the relationships Anna had been in as a mistress had ultimately ended badly for her, so too did it end badly for the women Saul slept with while staying with Anna. At this point, Anna has experienced such a relationship from both sides, as the mistress, and as the wife

Monday, October 22, 2012

"total sterility": denying the creative self


Anna claims if she had to label her dream that ends the black notebook, she would call it “total sterility,” recalling her earlier concerns of cleanliness in relation to her own body (period) and of immunization against cracking up (an ordering and separating of her identity from others).  This “sterility,” however, seems to be related to Anna’s writing/creative expression itself and rather illustrates her concern of not remembering “how Mayrose moved her eyes” or “how Paul laughed” (502).  In the dream, the cameras first remind—and then become—machine guns, suggesting that the capturing by film sterilizes the memory by not allowing it to be continually reinvented. 
Anna links the “untruthfulness” of her notebooks to her “sterility”(455), claiming that what she wrote down was not what she remembers.  Writing, then, as a form of “sterilizing” the self, contributes to Anna’s attempt to create an identity for herself but also undermines this very process by opposing the fluidity of memory and experience.  By reviewing her own notebooks (455), Anna further distances her present self from her past self and suggests that such a process of examination inevitably leads to a totalizing effect:  namely, that Anna uses her journals to draw conclusions about her past—“how the experience of being rejected by Michael changed, or apparently had changed, [her] whole personality” (my emphasis, 455).  The word “apparently” indicates Anna’s own skepticism regarding the truthfulness of the journals and distances Anna-as-reader from Anna-as-writer.